Last reviewed 16 Sept 2026 · 8 min read
Contract — legal essentials
A contract is an agreement enforceable by law (Indian Contract Act, 1872).
Essentials of a valid contract
- Offer (proposal) and acceptance.
- Lawful consideration.
- Competent parties — of the age of majority, sound mind, not disqualified by law.
- Free consent — not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake.
- Lawful object.
- Not expressly declared void; certainty and possibility of performance.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Valid contract | Satisfies all essentials — enforceable |
| Void contract | Not enforceable by law (e.g. unlawful object, or becomes impossible) |
| Voidable contract | Enforceable at the option of one party (e.g. consent obtained by coercion or fraud) |
| Void agreement | Never enforceable from the start |
Types of construction contracts
| Type | Features | Suitability / risk |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum contract | Contractor quotes a fixed total price for the complete work per drawings and specifications | Well-defined designs; contractor bears quantity risk; variations difficult to value |
| Item rate (unit rate / schedule) contract | Contractor quotes rates for each item in the bill of quantities; payment = measured quantity × rate | Most common in public works; owner bears quantity risk; flexible for quantity changes |
| Percentage rate contract | Contractor quotes a percentage above/below the departmental schedule of rates estimate | Simple evaluation; common in PWD works |
| Cost plus percentage | Actual cost + a percentage of cost as fee | Urgent/undefined works; no incentive to economise — cost rises with fee |
| Cost plus fixed fee | Actual cost + fixed fee | Some incentive to finish early; owner bears cost risk |
| Cost plus fluctuating fee / target cost | Fee varies with performance against a target cost (savings/overruns shared) | Encourages economy |
| Labour contract | Contractor supplies labour only; owner supplies materials | Small works; owner controls materials |
| Piece work | Payment per unit of work for small jobs without formal agreement | Petty works |
| Turnkey / EPC contract | Single contractor responsible for engineering, procurement and construction, handing over a ready-to-use facility, usually at a lump sum price | Owner transfers design and construction risk; single-point responsibility |
| Design-build | Same entity designs and constructs | Faster (overlapping design and construction) |
| Negotiated contract | Terms settled by negotiation with one or a few contractors | Specialised/urgent works |
Public–private partnership (PPP) models
| Model | Meaning |
|---|---|
| BOT (Build–Operate–Transfer) | Private party builds, operates (collects tolls/user charges) for a concession period, then transfers to government |
| BOOT (Build–Own–Operate–Transfer) | Private party also owns the asset during concession, then transfers |
| BOO (Build–Own–Operate) | Ownership stays with the private party (no transfer) |
| DBFOT (Design–Build–Finance–Operate–Transfer) | Private party designs and finances as well |
| BOT (Annuity) | Government pays fixed annuities to the concessionaire; traffic risk with government |
| HAM (Hybrid Annuity Model) | Used for national highways in India — government pays part of the project cost (commonly 40%) during construction; balance by the developer, recovered through annuity payments with interest; toll/revenue risk with government |
| EPC | Not PPP — government finances; contractor builds for a fixed price |
FIDIC forms of contract
Published by the International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC):
- Red Book — construction works designed by the employer.
- Yellow Book — plant and design-build (contractor designs).
- Silver Book — EPC/turnkey projects.
- Green Book — short form for smaller/simple works.
- White Book — client–consultant agreement.
Tendering process
- Preparation of tender documents — notice inviting tender (NIT), instructions to bidders, conditions of contract, specifications, drawings, bill of quantities, forms of bid and security.
- Notice inviting tender (NIT) — published on e-procurement portals/newspapers: name and estimated cost of work, time of completion, earnest money deposit (EMD), eligibility, dates of sale/submission/opening.
- Pre-qualification (for large works) — financial capacity, experience, equipment, personnel.
- Pre-bid meeting — clarification of queries; corrigenda/addenda.
- Submission — usually e-tendering; single-bid or two-bid system (technical bid + financial bid in separate envelopes/folders).
- Opening — technical bids first; financial bids of technically qualified bidders only.
- Evaluation — arithmetic checks, responsiveness; lowest evaluated responsive bidder (L1) for works; QCBS (quality and cost based selection) for consultancy.
- Negotiation (only as permitted by rules), letter of acceptance/award, performance security, signing of agreement, return of EMD to unsuccessful bidders.
Related terms
- Earnest money deposit (EMD) / bid security — ensures bidders do not withdraw or refuse to sign; forfeited if the bidder backs out. The amount is fixed by the department's rules (usually a small percentage of estimated cost, or bid security declaration).
- Unbalanced bid (front loading) — high rates for early items and low for later ones.
- Single tender, limited tender, open tender, global tender — depending on value and urgency.
- Cartelisation and collusive bidding — prohibited practices.
Important conditions of contract
| Condition | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Performance security (guarantee) | Ensures due performance; forfeited on default — a percentage of contract value as per rules |
| Security deposit / retention money | Deducted from running bills; released after defect liability period |
| Mobilisation advance | Interest-bearing or interest-free advance to start work, against bank guarantee, recovered from bills |
| Secured advance | Against materials brought to site |
| Price variation (escalation) clause | Adjusts payment for changes in prices of materials, labour and fuel using indices |
| Extension of time (EOT) | For delays not attributable to the contractor |
| Liquidated damages (LD) / compensation for delay | Pre-estimated damages for delay by the contractor, usually subject to a maximum percentage |
| Defect liability period (DLP) | Period after completion during which the contractor must rectify defects |
| Variations / extra and substituted items | Changes in quantity or scope, with rules for rates (deviation limits) |
| Termination / foreclosure | Rights to terminate for default or convenience |
| Force majeure | Relief for events beyond control |
| Dispute resolution clause | Procedure for settling disputes (e.g. dispute board, arbitration) |
Claims and dispute resolution
Common causes of disputes: delays, variations, unclear specifications, quantity differences, payment delays, escalation, unforeseen site conditions, termination.
| Method | Features |
|---|---|
| Negotiation | Parties settle directly — cheapest, fastest |
| Mediation | Neutral mediator facilitates settlement; non-binding unless agreed |
| Conciliation | Conciliator may propose terms; a settlement agreement signed by parties is binding (Part III of the 1996 Act) |
| Dispute Adjudication/Review Board (DAB/DRB) | Experts appointed during the project give decisions/recommendations quickly |
| Arbitration | Private adjudication by arbitrator(s); award is binding and enforceable like a court decree, with limited grounds of challenge |
| Litigation | Courts — slow and costly |
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (key points)
- Based on the UNCITRAL Model Law; amended notably in 2015, 2019 and 2021.
- An arbitration agreement must be in writing (clause in the contract or separate agreement).
- Parties may choose the number of arbitrators, but it must not be an even number; failing agreement, a sole arbitrator.
- Arbitrators must be independent and impartial (disclosure requirements introduced in 2015).
- Time limit for award (after 2015 amendment, Section 29A): generally 12 months from completion of pleadings, extendable by 6 months by consent of parties; further extension only by the court.
- Fast track procedure (Section 29B) — award on written pleadings, generally within 6 months, if parties agree.
- An award can be set aside by a court only on limited grounds (Section 34) — e.g. incapacity, invalid agreement, lack of proper notice, matters beyond the submission, improper composition, conflict with public policy.
- Interim measures by the court (Section 9) or the tribunal (Section 17).
Frequently tested points
- Valid contract essentials: offer and acceptance, consideration, competent parties, free consent, lawful object.
- Void (unenforceable) vs voidable (at the option of one party).
- Lump sum (fixed price, contractor bears quantity risk); item rate (BOQ rates, most common in PWD); percentage rate (above/below SOR); cost plus (owner bears cost risk; cost plus percentage gives no incentive to economise).
- Turnkey/EPC = single-point responsibility for design, procurement, construction.
- BOT, BOOT, BOO, DBFOT; HAM — government pays about 40% during construction, annuities later.
- FIDIC: Red (employer design), Yellow (design-build), Silver (EPC), Green (short form).
- Tender: NIT → pre-bid → submission (two-bid) → technical then financial opening → L1 → award → performance security → agreement.
- EMD — bid security; performance security — contract performance; retention released after DLP.
- LD — pre-estimated damages for delay; EOT for excusable delays; price variation clause for inflation.
- Arbitration Act 1996 (UNCITRAL); odd number of arbitrators; award within 12 (+6) months; Section 34 challenge; Section 29B fast track.
- Confusing EMD (bid security) with performance security.
- Calling EPC a PPP model.
- Treating mediation outcomes as binding without a signed settlement.
- Construction contracts must meet the essentials of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
- Lump sum, item rate, percentage rate, cost plus, labour, EPC/turnkey and design-build contracts allocate risk differently.
- PPP models such as BOT, BOOT, BOO, DBFOT and HAM involve private finance and operation; FIDIC forms provide international standard conditions.
- Tendering proceeds from NIT and bid documents through two-bid evaluation to award, with EMD and performance security.
- Key conditions govern advances, escalation, time extension, damages and defects, while disputes are resolved by negotiation, mediation, conciliation, dispute boards, arbitration or litigation.